I actually beta tested that Humax unit. That's a name I haven't heard in forever!
Absolutely. You are correct. When TiVo launched there was nothing like it (well, besides the short-lived ReplayTV). TiVo built best DVR money could buy for a very long time.
In addition to limited subscription revenue, it was just a very tough sell for most people when the cable company would just put a DVR under their TV for them. The same cable companies that intentionally made activating CableCARDs far more difficult than it ever should have been. TiVo was fighting a lot of battles they really had no chance of winning.
Nowadays TiVo's core business is licensing patents and retail DVR hardware is a thing of the past. 
We still eat popcorn out of a TiVo popcorn bowl in our house though!
@jsfullam I pushed a new experimental build just now. When you have the time, can you give it another test? Tuners should be released instantly, but in some situations it may take ~15 seconds to timeout.


