Allow the app to transcode, stripping commercials

Just read your Channels DVR 2021 Year in Review email blast and, true, you have added a lot of good stuff :slight_smile:
But one thing that's still missing, and would be really appreciated is app-based transcoding to a new file.

There are multiple ways this would be helpful (which, yes, I understand, means that after getting the basics in place, you want a UI that's powerful but not overwhelming...)
The obvious first use case is to transcode MPG2 to 264 or 265 (or, in year or so, 266) while stripping out commercials, to create a file people want to store in their permanent media collection. This is the sort of thing that's probably best handled by allowing people to choose a file and select "Transcode" from a popup menu, or a button, or whatever. Oldsters will remember versions of this in EyeTV.

But an interesting second use case is to transcode ephemeral content. 265 is now so much smaller than MPG2 that being able to shrink all one's ephemeral content effectively triples or so the size of one's Channels DVR storage, which is a nice little boost. And having the content completely in 265 probably means that all non-local viewing and random access will feel snappier without the delay inherent in having the server live-transcode from MPG2.

Doing this now also kinda sorta gets you readier for ATSC3, which right now is in place and sorta works as direct playback, but has a bunch of features not really integrated yet; a pipeline that looks more like
content -> 265 -> network playback seems like it might be an easier way to simultaneously support both ATSC and ATSC3.

Check out mcebuddy.

That's a Windows app. I run on Apple equipment.

LosslessCut and Avidemux are 2 options for macOS. Or even straight Ffmpeg.

I'm not looking for a video editing GUI. I'm looking for a SINGLE button I press that does what I want.

I am currently hacking an ffmpeg+handbrakeCLI bash script to do this, but honestly I'm getting too old for this $%^. I'd rather just pay someone to do it than waste hours of my limited remaining life fighting various conventions and trying to figure out how to force a command-line to do what I want.

In that case, there are several online marketplaces where you can solicit a developer to write your software for you if you don't wish to do it yourself.

Our take has been: 1) mpeg2 is already on its way out, and 2) disk space is cheap and only getting cheaper

Personally, I can't even get any mpeg2 content anymore. Cox converted all my PRIME channels, including locals, to h264. And my CONNECT picks up ATSC3 stations only which aren't mpeg2 either.

I'm curious what your motivation is here.. are you running out of disk space?

For me the single most important motivation is to be able to create content for my iPad for cases where I don't have network connectivity; most commonly: flying, and traveling to locations where internet may not be very good.

Others, of course, may have different use cases.

Okay, but you can do that with mpeg2 and using the new Downloads feature.

But maybe you're tight on disk space on your iPad?

That might be good enough (though being able to play "natively" on iPad, rather than forcing CPU for MPG2, thus saving battery is more to me than storage space).

More important is: is Downloads out of beta? You were talking about it a year ago, but in my iPad version, 5.1.1, I still see no way to perform a download. There's nothing that says "Download" to me in the popup menu, which is where I would expect it to be, and the only web references I can find are comments about the beta a year or two ago.

Testflight Beta

Ah, I see. You have hooked up Downloads for TV series, but not for movies!
Which is a nice start, but does not do what I want which is more on the movie side...

The downloads feature was added last month. It works with movies and tv shows.

When I long click on a TV show (in the Recently Updated section) I get a menu that includes Download.
I do not get this menu if I click anywhere else - not on TV Shows in "Up Next", not on items in "Continue Watching", and not in "Recently Added Movies".

Given what you say, I assume this is just a silly UI oversight bug?

It does show up for me.

Maybe you already selected download.. that's the only reason it wouldn't appear.

Click the download icon at the top right of Library to check.

Am I missing something dumb? Like I said iPad version 5.1.1

May be a bug on iPad then.

What if you do a regular tap on the movie and hit More

Same deal. Nothing about Download there.

So I agree this is a good initial solution once the UI bugs are cleaned up. (There is a similar wart -- design or bug? -- in that individual episodes of a show cannot be downloaded...)

Transcoding to 264or 265 (for battery life) would be a very nice next step, but I can live with MPG2 downloads as better than nothing.

I didn't know that downloads were released in v5.1.1 !
No mention of it in the release notes https://getchannels.com/releases/#ios
I would think it would show as a new feature