Commercial Editing Failure

I am trying to use the web interface to edit commercials on a TV show. I go in and clean up the block checks and save. When I reopen the saves did not take properly. I try once again to clean up the commercial blocks but the save button is disabled. I've tried asking the app to re-scan for commercials but I still can not get the system to save my edits.

I think that when automatic commercial detection on tve channels is enabled you cant edit the markers. Look in the logs at the recording, I think it shows (ADS) when it is automatic.

Works for me?

It looks like it works... try making a change and saving it. Then go back in and it reverts...

Not for me.
Simple before and after.


Marked all blocks as program and saved.

If it helps, I tried it on two recordings from the Magnolia channel on two servers.
Both are running in docker containers on Synology NAS's and at v2023.08.25.0606.

For the two recordings I was able to edit commercials on

2023/08/28 12:30:27.507551 [ADS] Detected 2 commercial markers in file-2367: TV/Canary Magnolia Recording/Canary Magnolia Recording 2023-08-28-1220.mpg
2023/08/28 13:30:26.558516 [ADS] Detected 4 commercial markers in file-2258: TV/Canary Magnolia Recording/Canary Magnolia Recording 2023-08-28-1320.mpg

Are there any errors appearing in the DVR log when you try to edit and save the changes?

Other than DVR version differences, this is all I could think of. Both of my servers are set like this.

The forum won't let me add another post here, so adding to this one.
Just tried again after updating one of my servers to v2023.08.28.2117
It's not generating all the preview images.
2023/08/28 16:52:11.255227 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 109.57: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:11.267657 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:19.570812 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 487.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:19.908997 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:20.750901 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:23.201622 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 501.26: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:24.956107 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 505.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:25.520492 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 506.61: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.935995 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.937145 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.948183 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 487.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.950911 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.320763 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.330522 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.331357 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed

But after going back in to Edit Commercials 5 or 6 times, it finally generated all the images and I was able to edit and save.

Marked all blocks as program

It's having a problem generating preview images

Log
2023/08/28 16:52:11.255227 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 109.57: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:11.267657 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:19.570812 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 487.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:19.908997 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:20.750901 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:23.201622 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 501.26: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:24.956107 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 505.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:52:25.520492 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 506.61: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.935995 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.937145 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.948183 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 487.59: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:01.950911 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.320763 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 219.14: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.330522 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 496.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 16:53:50.331357 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 492.15: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:00.504323 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 187.39: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:00.508046 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.08: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:00.511638 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 62.46: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:00.511819 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 124.93: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:03.946510 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:08.930816 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 316.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:16.807067 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 405.37: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:18.179687 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 409.86: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:18.239537 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 414.35: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:20.360920 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 418.84: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:21.928904 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 423.32: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:23.259517 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 427.81: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:23.286243 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 432.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:25.432593 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 436.79: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:27.041758 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 441.27: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:28.357854 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 445.76: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:28.381753 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 450.25: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:30.647644 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 454.74: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:32.117922 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 459.23: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:33.469976 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 463.71: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:33.842573 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 468.2: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:36.018680 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 472.69: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:38.609901 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 476.98: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:38.737610 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 478: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:40.703025 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 481.09: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:41.117555 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 482.12: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:05:43.637760 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 551.03: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:29.499447 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 187.39: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:29.501616 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.08: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:29.508448 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 124.93: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:29.510583 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:29.525784 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 62.46: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:34.547888 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 316.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:34.555565 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 409.86: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:34.558915 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 414.35: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:34.562678 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 418.84: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:39.363614 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 423.32: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:39.637102 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 432.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:39.637369 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 441.27: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:39.641016 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 427.81: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:39.651075 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 436.79: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:44.525714 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 445.76: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:44.746111 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 450.25: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:44.758086 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 463.71: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:44.758455 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 459.23: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:44.758664 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 454.74: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:49.841968 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 472.69: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:49.874741 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 476.98: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:49.875222 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 478: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:06:49.875227 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 481.09: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:42.502594 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 124.93: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:42.504062 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.08: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:42.505196 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 187.39: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:42.513051 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:47.416668 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 316.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:47.535221 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 409.86: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:47.549135 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 414.35: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:47.552311 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 418.84: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:52.496544 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 427.81: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:52.547067 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 432.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:52.573308 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 436.79: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:52.596165 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 445.76: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:57.574998 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 454.74: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:57.576771 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 459.23: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:57.598540 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 450.25: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:57.618146 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 463.71: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:07:57.626044 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 472.69: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:10.210510 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:10.210927 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.08: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:10.219639 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 316.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:10.221175 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 124.93: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:10.226840 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 187.39: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:15.252886 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 414.35: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:15.255416 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 409.86: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:15.256043 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 418.84: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:15.264722 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 427.81: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:15.267817 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 432.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:20.335805 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 436.79: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:20.337997 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 459.23: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:20.368691 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 450.25: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:20.368869 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 454.74: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:09:20.343495 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 445.76: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:11.316485 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 187.39: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:11.319453 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.08: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:11.334438 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 124.93: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:11.341256 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 251.7: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:11.352633 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 316.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:16.359628 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 409.86: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:16.374815 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 414.35: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:16.379826 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 418.84: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:16.382366 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 427.81: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:16.388469 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 432.3: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:21.425182 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 436.79: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:21.459188 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 445.76: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:21.450543 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 459.23: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:21.454926 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 454.74: signal: killed
2023/08/28 17:11:21.461293 [ERR] Failed to generate preview @ 450.25: signal: killed

But not on my other server still running v2023.08.25.0606

This topic was automatically closed 365 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.