Currently recording pop-up

I have a question.
If I wanna tune to a channel that is currently being recorded, I'll get a popup asking me if I wanna watch the recording, or watch live.

(As u can see in the photo)

But what I thought is that to turn this off, I'd turn off the setting, "watch from library prompt" (as shown in 2nd photo here)

But I turned the setting off, but I still get this popup "currently recording".
Is that not what this setting is supposed to control? Did I misunderstand it? Or..... Is it just not working right?
Any help on this would be appreciated.

The Watch from Library prompt is different, its only for things which are not still recording.

So I guess there is no setting to turn that off? Oh well. Not horrible