NBC & Descriptive Video Services

Greetings,
I am a blind Channels user using a 3-tuner HDHomeRun and subscribed to Xfinity.

I am unsure if a recent-ish update or NBC changing things up but I no longer get Descriptive Video Services (audio description) on recorded NBC shows that have always had it before (or at least since I've been using Channels)

I go through the steps of selecting Descriptive Video Services and then back out of the menu and sometimes there is no audio at all, sometimes just the program audio, but never descriptive audio services. Wondering if there are any other users that have experienced this issue? Would greatly appreciate any thoughts, experiences, or suggestions.
Thanks,
Jeff

Hi Jeff,
Willing to bet the system isn't recording the described audio portion of the broadcast.
Are you getting the nbc channels locally on hdhomerun?

2 Likes

There are a lot of variables that could be causing this. I found a post on the Reddit community r/blind from a few months ago with a comment that their local NBC affiliate completely turned it off due to technical issues.

I would try opening the recording in VLC and find out if the descriptive audio works there. If not, it’s probably not a Channels issue and points towards an issue with either the NBC affiliate or Xfinity.

1 Like

Yes, I'm recording the NBC shows with the HDHomeRun. I'm guessing there is no way to record the audio description any longer? Last year I lost audio description on ABC shows. As of now I'm still getting audio description on CBS shows. All recorded with the 3-tuner HDHomeRun played back via Channels on the Apple TV4k.

If there is a way to get the audio description back, it certainly would be ideal.
I appreciate your reply.

So I just tested it and descriptive audio is working on my local PBS station in Channels.

2 Likes

Can you verify that your local nbc station has a described audio track?
I know for a fact that most of the programing on NBC is on peacock and one can get audio discription.

1 Like

NBC is airing live programming right now, so it’s not a good time to test. The track appears in the audio selector, but it’s just playing the main audio track. I’ll record Dateline at midnight and a sitcom at 8pm tomorrow, then report back.

1 Like

I know last TV season (Sep-May), there was no issue receiving audio description on NBC programming. Suppose I will need to speak with engineering somehow.

I tested it tonight and it’s not working on my local NBC affiliate either. I recorded it from an antenna.

1 Like

I should add that it was a show that AFB said would have audio descriptions tonight and the beginning of the episode showed the audio description icon. I selected the described video service audio channel and it just played the main audio track with no described audio.

1 Like

Very interesting, admittedly an extremely small sample size. I am leaning on the side of the networks failing to send the audio description track to the affiliate stations. As I mentioned earlier, ABC stopped having audio description last year...last night we watched an ABC show, RJ Decker from our Channels DVR through our ATV and it did have the audio description track.

I appreciate your time and follow-up on this issue.
Jeff

1 Like

I would try to find the phone number for your station's broadcast engineer and ask them. You could also file a complaint through the FCC

2 Likes

Excellent suggestion, especially filing a complaint with the FCC.

Over the past few days I have been playing around with both live and recorded NBC content. I think this may be a show specific issue or perhaps an issue with a few shows, but I don't think it is an issue with NBC as a whole.

Playing a few shows live the audio description has worked as expected, the same with a few recorded shows, including Saturday Night Live.

I really appreciate the time, thoughts and opinions shared by the community. Sincere thanks
Jeff