I’ve picked up two on eBay. Got the 2nd just a couple weeks ago for ~$15 (new, box was beat up but remote brand new).
I got the first one for an ATV that didn’t have a remote for since I didn’t want to pay $60 for the Siri remote but after using both for a year I think I prefer the Spectrum. My comparison below..
Spectrum:
- Guide button
- Channel up/down
- More intuitive button layout
- Siri/Mic button not on the side where it gets pushed accidentally
- Backlit!
- A little larger so doesn’t disappear into the couch cushions as often
Siri:
- Touch capability
- Rechargeable
I sometimes miss the touch capability - mostly for scrubbing. (I remembered that I can scrub from my phone and it’s actually a better experience)
Pressing up/down on the D pad works for most functions that use swipe gestures. There was one app that lost some minor functionality without swipe but can’t recall what it was.
I’ve been using the Spectrum on the tv I use the most but recently swapped for the Siri to see for sure which I prefer. The touch capability is more of an annoyance to me since I’m always accidentally touching. Yeah, I know you can turn touch off and I’ve experimented with that but…at that point I may as well use the Spectrum.