No longer prompted to watch from beginning: recording in progress

Is there a specific criteria to meet (select from On Now vs Guide) in order to be prompted to watch from beginning vs watch now on an in-progress recording?

When I setup the system last week I got prompted on several occasions, but it no longer does this. Looking at the log it jumps straight to sharing the existing connection the DVR is using and joins the client in progress.

I have tried with tuner sharing on and off and don't seem to see a difference for this feature.

Latest versions clients and server. Clients are shield and 2gen firetv. Server is running on dedicated shield.

Thanks,

We've a Synology NAS and a gen. 2 FireTV. We still get that prompt.

Thanks - do you get that prompt any time you select a recording in progress, whether from On Now or the guide?

Couldn't say for sure, because I always use "On Now." I'll test it first chance I get.