Comedy Central seems to get no ad detection/skipping right now, at least for The Daily Show. And I'm pretty sure it used to.
IIRC there is no list of channels it works on.
If the stream (TVE, M3U) meets the criteria it will use it.
The stream would have to be recorded long enough to include some ad breaks.
There is a block-list (somewhere internally, unpublished) that keeps it from being used on known problem channels.
1 Like
On some TVE Channels the regular comskip does a better job for ex WETV. TNT etc ...They do not have those BRB banners.
What do you mean here?
If you are referencing the full-screen placards inserted where local ads would be inserted, then I think you are incorrect. I have seen those used when "smart" detection was also used. (My personal use-case with channels using those placards is with Discovery Networks, but they all use "smart" detection and are quite accurate: Food, HGTV, TLC)
1 Like
That's odd. I've had no issues using comskip with channels for The Daily Show, albeit with my cablecard/HDHR prime.
You missed the topic title.
I want to make sure if it is enabled for all Channels and if it is ... is there a cli to disable it on certain channels.
Works great for CNN. Not 100% reliable but pretty close.
Is there a setting in Channels DVR where we can manually assign season passes or recordings to use comskip vs. smart ad detection? Or it it automatic and we can just manually run comskip on recordings a second time afterwards?
It is automatic, and cannot be disabled. The channels it runs on is set within the DVR by an internal list, and it is neither user-facing nor editable.
If you are dissatisfied with the commercial markers it provides, you can manually run Comskip on the recording afterwards, but beware that Comskip's detection may be worse, and there is no way to restore the previous "smart" detected commercials after you run Comskip.
So the disable Comskip from this channel will not work either ?
You can disable Comskip manually for the channel, but it is unnecessary. If the channel uses the smart detection, Comskip is not run after a recording finishes.
Channels with smart detection essentially have Comskip disabled for them, with the added benefit of a lightweight commercial detection that happens in real-time.
Just like with Channels that you have manually disabled Comskip for, manually choosing to detect commercials on a recording will still run Comskip, regardless of whether it was disabled or not.
1 Like
TVE WETV used the regular comskip not smart ad detection ... It must still be on the do not run list.
Recording for job 1708894926-ch6089 from TVE-Comcast_SSO ch6089 into "TV\S.W.A.T\S.W.A.T. S04E07 2021-01-13 Under Fire 2024-02-25-1302.mpg" for 58m53.2039596s
Running commercial detection on file 6160 (TV\S.W.A.T\S.W.A.T. S04E07 2021-01-13 Under Fire 2024-02-25-1302.mpg)
Commercial detection is perfect no errors marking commercials. This is why I would like to see an OPTION excluding certain Channels from Smart detection which is not always smart.
If regular Comskip was run, it was not on the "do not run list" as you call it. If WE was part of the smart detection, commercial detection would have happened, Comskip would not have been executed, and your logs would have reflected such. So by your own observation, WE is not subject to the smart detection.
What you are stating is that Comskip ran as expected, and you were happy with the result. So what is the issue?
(Since ad networks, streams, and CDNs seem to be shared across a family of networks, it looks like not only would WeTV not be party to smart detections, but all AMC Networks streams: AMC, BBCA, Sundance, IFC, as well as WeTV.)
Regular comskip ran automatically on the TVE Channel that I had asked @tmm1 to exclude from Smart detection... that is exactly how I like it ... exclude it from smart detection and run regular comskip.exe automatically. I would like the ability to exclude channels from smart detection and still run comskip app automatically.
################################################################
Generated using donator Comskip 0.82.011
Time at start of run:
Sun Feb 25 14:05:55 2024
################################################################
Mpeg: W:\DVR\TV\S.W.A.T\S.W.A.T. S04E07 2021-01-13 Under Fire 2024-02-25-1302.mpg
Exe C:\ProgramData\ChannelsDVR\latest\comskip.exe
Logo: W:\DVR\Logs\comskip\6160\video.logo.txt
Ini: comskip.ini
PS I have my own INI.
So what exactly was the point of your post? As I understand the situation as stated:
- you have previously experienced errors with "smart" detection on WeTV TVE streams
- you requested that "smart" detection be disabled for that stream
- "smart" detection for that stream has been removed, making it a target for regular Comskip
So what's the point?
(While making my response, you amended yours. So this is the crux:
Which is separate and different from the OP. If this is truly what you want, then create a separate thread. Instead, be genuine about what you want:
Sometimes I don't like smart detection, and want the ability to disable it for a particular channel.
Is that so difficult?)
1 Like
Why do you always have to be condescending. I want the ability to be able to do it on my own DVR .. Right now, I believe if I ask for a channel to be disabled from smart detection... it will disable it for everybody.
1 Like
I come across as a "jerk" (edited out from your original post) and condescending because I don't deal well with individuals who have access to the knowledge and answers to the questions they ask, but choose not to avail themselves of ...
As frequently as you comment, I would have thought you have familiarity with the forum; however you seem incapable of searching for answers that have already been given ... if you choose to revile me for my disdain of your inability to reference answers already given, I will gladly accept it.
1 Like
Bye I made my point.